Mark Butcher has suggested Joe Root’s increased workload with the ball could be hampering his output with the bat, in the context of England’s No.4 struggling to maintain his usual consistency on their ongoing tour of India.
Root is regarded as one of the best Test batsmen in England’s history, averaging just under 50 and scoring over 11,000 runs. However, he has struggled in India this winter and in his three Tests so far he has scored a high score of 29 at an average of 12.83.
Root’s averages under the tutelage of Ben Stokes and Brendon McCullum are slightly better than his career numbers, but much of the criticism is based on whether he fits their playing style. I am. The debate became even more heated in the first innings against Rajkot when he was caught trying to bowl to Jasprit Bumrah and was sent off. Root’s recent performance in India has also been poor. Since his memorable double century in Chennai to open the 2021 England tour, he has hit a high score of 40 in 13 innings.
Butcher proposed another theory. In other words, Root’s extra burden as an off-spinner is affecting his batting performance. With Stokes unable to bowl, Root is effectively England’s top-six all-rounder for this series, having hit 107 overs in the series so far, with a previous record of 63 in England’s 3-0 win over Pakistan last winter. far exceeded the maximum workload. England’s first innings was the only time in this series that Root exceeded his 20, and it was also the only time he batted before bowling during this period.
If you expect your best batsman to be a true all-rounder and bowl as many overs as a front-line spinner, then don’t be surprised if you don’t get performance from him with the bat. “I want it,” Butcher said. “I thought that idea came from a time when people talked about Joe Root being the only spinner in the England squad in a more nutritious environment and said that was nonsense. And I still do. I think we need him to be there” to produce the results we expect from him with the bat. ”
No one had a problem when Joe Root averaged 65.58 in 2023 while Bazballing.
The same pranks we now consider foolish were often praised by the same people.
– Abhishek Mukherjee (@ovshake42) 17. February 2024
Butcher also pointed out that England’s inexperienced and slow bowling attack was a key difference from India. Rehan Ahmed, who has played three Tests due to Leach being injured, is the most experienced frontline spinner. On the other hand, India had R Ashwin in Rajkot where he reached 500 wickets and with 3,000 runs he was one of only 12 all-rounders in history to achieve his double of 250 wickets. You can rely on Ravindra Jadeja.
“With Leach’s injury, we don’t know what England can do, but it shows a little bit how foolish India are to launch a green spin attack like this,” Butcher said. “Rehan Ahmed and (Tom) Hartley were really good. But when you think about the throws that happen when you bowl first and third instead of second and fourth, players who have just started the game do well. We need a little more.’ Or there are people like Joe Root who are part-time spin bowlers who can hold down the fort for you. This is the fundamental reason why India were favorites even before the start. ”
England suffered a record defeat in Rajkot, losing 2-1 with two games remaining. The series continues with his Friday, February 23 lunch.
Subscribe to the Wisden Cricket YouTube channel for post-match analysis, player interviews, and much more.
